Myths versus facts
Twelve mix-ups, carefully untangled
12 common mix-ups, answered from official Natural History Museum wording, without blending dates or names that the official pages themselves keep distinct.
Myth. Ichthyosaurs were dinosaurs.
Fact. Official wording is the opposite: “Though they’re both reptiles and lived at the same time, dinosaurs aren’t closely related to ichthyosaurs. The dinosaurs lived on land, whereas ichthyosaurs never left the water.”[source]
Myth. They were literal sea dragons, or only a legend.
Fact. Their remains “have become part of sea dragon mythology,” but “we now know that these animals weren’t legends, but real reptiles that lived millions of years ago.”[source]
Myth. They laid eggs on beaches, like turtles.
Fact. A Stenopterygius fossil, official wording says, reveals that they “didn’t lay eggs but instead had live births.” They “gave birth to live young in the open ocean” and “never had to return to land to reproduce or give birth.”[source]
Myth. Because they looked like dolphins, they could echolocate.
Fact. “While some ichthyosaurs looked similar to dolphins, there’s no evidence that they could echolocate in the same way.” The similar shape is officially described as convergent evolution.[source]
Myth. The name Proteosaurus is the one that stuck.
Fact. Sir Everard Home used that name in 1819. Official wording says “this name didn’t catch on.” Scientists used Ichthyosaurus, coined by Charles Konig in 1817.[source]
Myth. The Lyme Regis animal was the first ichthyosaur anyone had ever found.
Fact. The collection page does call that Temnodontosaurus platyodon skull “the first ever discovered.” The Mary Anning page says that although it “wasn’t the first ichthyosaur to be found, it was the first to be scientifically studied and described in literature.” A discover page mentions Edward Lhwyd’s illustration in 1695. Those wordings stay with their pages.[source][source][source]
Myth. Joseph found the skull in one agreed official year.
Fact. A collection page says 1810. A discover page, and the Mary Anning page, say 1811. This site keeps both.[source][source][source]
Myth. The 10-metre Rutland animal is the largest ichthyosaur known anywhere.
Fact. Official wording says it is “currently the largest ichthyosaur ever found in the UK.” The same page estimates Ichthyotitan severnensis, known from Somerset jaw fossils, at as much as 25 metres.[source]
Myth. The Stuttgart Temnodontosaurus trigonodon photograph is the Rutland specimen.
Fact. That still was photographed at the Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde Stuttgart in 2010. Official pages describe the Rutland animal as found at Rutland Water in 2021. This site does not treat the photograph as that specimen.
Myth. The file caption of 21 metres on a Shonisaurus sikanniensis still is the same statement as the official 15–21 metre range.
Fact. Official wording says species such as Shastasaurus and Shonisaurus “still measured between 15 and 21 metres long,” as a group range. The 21-metre figure on that file stays with the file.[source]
Myth. Ichthyosaurus means they were fish, or lizards.
Fact. The discover page says the name means “fish reptile.” The Mary Anning page says the animal was named Ichthyosaurus, or “fish lizard” — “though we now know it was neither fish nor lizard, but a marine reptile.”[source][source]
Myth. There is one official extinction year, 94 million or 90 million, and the other is a mistake.
Fact. A discover page gives a range ending “about 94 million years ago in the Late Cretaceous,” and later says “around 90 million years ago” they “finally faced an extinction they couldn’t survive.” Both official sentences are kept.[source]
Enjoyed this sea-dragon desk?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next fossils.im site get built.